No. 433.
Mr. Manning to Mr. Bayard.

No. 76.]

Sir: Referring to my No. 34, of December 11 last, with inclosures, relative to the loss of certain Government property by troops of the United States in January, 1886, will engaged in the pursuit of hostile Chiricahua Indians in Mexican territory, I have the honor to inclose herewith copy and translation of Mr. Mariscal’s reply upon that subject.

You will perceive “that 5 mules, 4 sets of harness, 6 halters, 5 blankets, 2 saddles, 2 bridles, 2 cotton blankets, and 2 leading-ropes are at the disposal of the war department” (of Mexico).

Mr. Mariscal further says:

I beg to ask your excellency, to whom shall be delivered the 5 mules and the other property specified, as also the amount estimated by the United States Government to be the value of the mule and blanket lacking; with the understanding that the $500 demanded for damages sustained, as specified in the note to which I have the honor to reply, shall, without entering into a discussion as to the amount stated, be paid by the Government of Mexico to the person appointed therefor?

I am, etc.,

T. C. Manning.
[Page 692]
[Inclosure 1 in No. 76.—Translation.]

Mr. Mariscal to Mr. Manning.

Mr. Minister: In due time I had the honor to receive your excellency’s note of December 11 last, in which you were pleased to request the return of 6 mules and other property delivered in January, 1888, by Lieutenant Maus, U. S. Army, to Chihuahua State forces, or else the payment of $2,000, the estimated value of the property lost and the damage sustained.

Having advised the Government of Chihuahua touching this demand, and requesting information relative thereto, I am informed, as your excellency will see by the accompanying copy, that 5 mules, 4 sets of harness, 6 halters, 5 blankets, 2 saddles, 2 bridles, 2 guangoches (cotton blankets), and 2 leading-ropes are at the disposal of the war department, there lacking of the property given up by Lieutenant Maus 1 mule, which died, and a blanket, which was lost.

In view of this I beg to ask your excellency to whom shall be delivered the 5 mules and the other property specified, as also the amount estimated by the United States Government to be the value of the mule and blanket lacking; with the understanding that the $500 demanded for damages sustained, as specified in the note to which I have the honor to reply, shall, without entering into a discussion as to the amount stated, be paid by the Government of Mexico to the person appointed therefor. I have, etc.,

Igno. Mariscal.
[Inclosure 2 in No. 76.—Translation.]

Mr. Escudero to Mr. Mariscal.

Mexican Republic.

[Department of war and marine, first section, second desk. No. 33710.]

In a telegram yesterday the governor of the State of Chihuahua advised me:

“By direction of the minister of foreign affairs I place at your disposition 5 mules, 4 sets of harness, G halters, 5 sweat blankets, 2 Texan saddles, 2 bridles, 2 cotton blankets, and 2 leading-ropes, which, with 1 mule that died and a blanket lost, were delivered by Lieutenant Maus, U. S. Army, to the officer of the section, Santa Ana Perez, who a year ago was in conflict with Apaches.”

Which I have the honor to advise you, begging that you will inform me to whom the mules and property referred to shall be delivered.

Liberty and constitution.


Ignacio m. Escudero,
Sub-Secretary ad interim.

By order of Secretary.