File No. 861.00/3212

The Chargé in Great Britain ( Laughlin) to the Secretary of State

[Extract]

Sir: With reference to my despatch No. 9990 of October 2, 1918,3 forwarding a memorandum on conditions in Russia, I have the honor [Page 714] to transmit, herewith enclosed, copies of certain documents1 supplementary thereto, also prepared by Mr. Norman C. Armour, formerly Second Secretary of the American Embassy at Vologda. …

(c) A communication from M. Chicherin, Commissar for Foreign Affairs, to Major Allen Wardwell, relative to alleged atrocities committed by anti-Bolshevik forces. …

I have [etc.]

Irwin Laughlin
[Enclosure]

The Soviet Commissar for Foreign Affairs ( Chicherin) to the Chief of the American Red Cross Commission to Russia ( Wardwell)2

Dear Sir: It is only because the body which you represent is not a political organization that I can find it compatible with my position not to repudiate offhand your intervention as a misplaced interference in the affairs of a foreign state, but to enter in the friendly spirit corresponding to the character of your organization into a discussion of the matter involved. You affirm that your organization did not hesitate to condemn acts of barbarity on the part of our adversaries. Where are these utterances of condemnation? When and in what form did the American Red Cross protest when the streets of Samara were filled with corpses of young workers shot in batches by America’s allies, or when the prisons of Omsk were filled with tens of thousands of the flower of the working class and the best of them executed without trial, or when just now in Novorossiisk the troops of England’s mercenary Alexeev murdered in cold blood 7,000 wounded who were left behind by our retreating army, or when the Cossacks of the same Alexeev murdered without distinction the young men of their own race in whom they see a revolutionary vanguard? I would be very glad to learn what the American Red Cross has done in order to publicly brand these untold atrocities, the everyday work of our enemies, everywhere practised by them upon our friends when they have the power to do it. But are these the only atrocities around us? In a wider field, at the present period when the oligarchs who are the rulers of the world drench the earth with streams of blood, cover it with heaps of corpses and whole armies of maimed and fill the whole world with unspeakable sufferings, why do you turn your indignation against those who, rising against this whole system of violence, oppression and murder that bears as if for the sake of mockery the name of civilization, those I repeat who in their desperate struggle against the ruling system of the present world are compelled by their very position in the furnace of a civil war to strike the class foes with whom the life and struggle is raging? And in a still wider field are not the sacrifices still greater, still more innumerable, which are exacted every day on the battlefield of labor by the ruling system of exploitation which grinds youth and life force and happiness of the multitude for the sake of the profits of the few? How can I characterize the humanity of the American Red Cross which is dumb to the system of everyday murder and turns against those who have dared to rise against it and surrounded by mortal enemies from all sides are compelled to strike? Against these fighters who have thrust themselves into the fire of battle for a whole new system of human society you are not even able to be otherwise than unjust. Our adversaries are not executed as you affirm for holding other political views than ourselves, but for taking part in the most terrible [Page 715] of battles, in which no weapon is left untouched against us, no crime is left aside and no atrocities are considered too great when the power belongs to them. Is it not known to you that by the decree of September 3 the death sentences are applied only for distinct crimes, and besides banditism and ordinary crimes, they are to be applied for participation in the White Guard movement, that is, the movement which helps to surround us everywhere with death snares, which unceasingly attacks us with fire and sword and every possible misfortune and wishes to prepare for us, if only it had the power to do so, complete extermination? You speak of execution of 500 persons in Petrograd as of one particularly striking instance of acts of like character. As for the number it is the only one. Among these 500, 200 were executed on the ground of the decision of the local organization, to whom they were very well known as most active and dangerous counter-revolutionaries, and 300 had been selected already some time ago as belonging to the vanguard of the counterrevolutionary movement. In the passion of the struggle tearing our whole people, do you not see the sufferings, untold during generations, of all the unknown millions, who were dumb during centuries and whose concentrated despair and rage have at last burst into the open, passionately longing for a new life, for the sake of which they have the whole existing fabric to remove? In the great battles of mankind, hatred and fury are even so unavoidable as in every battle and in every struggle. Do you not see the beauties of the heroism of the working class, trampled under the feet of everybody who were above them until now, and now rising in fury and passionate devotion and enthusiasm to recreate the whole world and the whole life of mankind? Why are you blind to all this in the same way as you are dumb to the system of atrocities against which this working class has risen? It is only natural then if you are unjust against those whom you lightheartedly condemn, if you distort even the facts of the case, if you see wanton vengeance against persons of other views there, where in reality there is the most terrible, the most passionate, the most furious battle of one world against the other, in which our enemies with deadly weapons are lurking behind every street corner, and in which the executions of which you speak, executions of real and deadly enemies, are insignificant in comparison with the horrors which these enemies try to prepare for us, and in comparison with the immeasurable horrors of the whole system with which we are at present at grips in a life and death struggle.

I remain,

Yours truly,

G. Chicherin
  1. Not printed.
  2. Not printed.
  3. See ante, p. 685.