File No. 711.5914/238½

The Danish Minister to the Secretary of State

Dear Mr. Secretary of State: Since writing you on October 2nd I have received by mail from the Danish Minister of Foreign Affairs the text of the note from Mr. Egan to the Minister, dated September 11th, and of the reply of the Minister to Mr. Egan, dated September 13th, both relating to the property of the Danish National Church in the Danish West Indies.

I beg to enclose herewith copies of the two notes.

It appears from this that the reply of the Danish Minister of Foreign Affairs was also in the English language, and I beg to propose that this English text should be used in the exchange of notes between us to which you refer in your letter to me of October 5th just received.

[Page 683]

The reason for this request is, that the Danish text which I sent you on October 2nd is somewhat uncertain owing to errors of transmission in the corresponding cablegram. I note for instance, that when the Danish text in the last phrase but one says: forsaavidt angaaer dens Ejendoms—og Beskyttelsesret over den Kirkelige Ejendom, it should have been Benyttelsesret or Brugsret, in order to correspond to the now received English text.

I understand from your letter of yesterday that the note which you propose to hand to me will be identical with the note of Mr. Egan of September 11th, and as soon as you shall advise me of the exact terms of the text, I will obtain renewed authority from the Danish Government to proceed to the exchange.

I am [etc.]

C. Brun
[Inclosure 1]

Minister Egan to the Minister of Foreign Affairs

No. 678

Your Excellency: In reference to our conversation on the matter of the relation of the United States to the rights of the Established Church in the Danish West Indies, I have the honor to repeat that the Secretary of State proposes to exchange notes with the Danish Minister in Washington, and he suggests on his side a note in the following substance and form:

[Quotes paragraphs 3, 4 and 5 of Department’s telegram of September 9, 1916, ante.]

My Government will be pleased if this exchange of notes can be expedited as quickly as possible.

I avail myself [etc.]

Maurice Francis Egan
[Inclosure 2]

The Minister of Foreign Affairs to Minister Egan

Monsieur le Ministre: With reference to your note of 11 inst. concerning the relation of the United States to the rights of the Established Church in the Danish West Indies and to the provisions referring to this point in the convention between the United States and Denmark ceding to the States the Danish West Indian Islands, I have the honor to state that it is understood and accepted by the Government of Denmark and the Government of the United States that the provisions of this convention referring to the property and funds belonging to the Danish National Church in the Danish West Indian Islands shall not be taken and construed by the High Contracting Parties as imposing any trust upon the United States with respect to any funds belonging to the Danish National Church in the Danish West Indian Islands or in which the said church may have an interest; nor as imposing upon the United States any duty or responsibility with respect to the management of any property belonging to said church beyond protecting said church in possession and use of church property as stated in said convention in the same manner and to the same extent only as other churches shall be protected in the possession and use of their several properties.

It will be evident from the above, that the Danish Government accept the understanding as to the meaning and construction of the provisions of the said convention in accordance with the resolution of the United States’ Senate concerning the question of the rights of the church in the islands.

I avail [etc.]

[File copy not signed]