File No. 861.48/203

The Ambassador in Germany (Gerard) to the Secretary of State

No. 3904

Sir: With reference to the Department’s unnumbered instruction of July 21, 1916,1 enclosing the President’s autograph letter to the German Emperor on the subject of relief to destitute non-combatant inhabitants of Poland, which the Embassy duly transmitted to His Imperial Majesty through the medium of the Imperial Foreign Office, I now have the honor to enclose herewith a letter addressed to the Imperial German Embassy in Washington containing the Emperor’s reply to the President, which the Foreign Office has requested me to forward in the diplomatic pouch in view of the uncertainty of the open mails at the present time.

Although no office copy of the Emperor’s letter was transmitted to the Embassy, I have had made, for the Department’s information, a translation of the office copy destined for the German Embassy in Washington, contained in the unsealed envelope, and enclose it herewith.

I have [etc.]

James W. Gerard
[Enclosure—Translation]

Emperor William II to President Wilson

Mr. President: The Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of the United States of America at my Court, Mr. James W. Gerard, has transmitted [Page 910] to me the communication of July 20, according to which you, Mr. President, felt inclined to suggest a fresh consideration of the ways and means which might enable the American people to relieve the distress of the non-combatant inhabitants of Poland.

The supposition, which you make, that overwhelming disasters have befallen millions of non-combatant inhabitants of Poland and that millions of innocent people are threatened with death by slow or rapid starvation, was unhappily true of the past year, when the Russian Army, retreating from my troops and the Austro-Hungarians, were systematically endeavoring to turn the country into a desert, burning the villages, destroying the crops, and attempting to drag away the inhabitants, women, children, old men. As soon as the German administration had been established, it did all in its power to relieve the inhabitants of the occupied territory, regardless of racial origin or political sentiments, by distributing food, providing for lodging, coping with epidemic diseases. To-day, after a year has passed, the results of these labors may be reviewed. The administration which I established has succeeded in alleviating to a great extent the distress caused by the Russian methods of warfare— which no one can regret more than I—and in protecting the occupied territories from the worst misery. My administration has furnished, for the benefit of the occupied and for the greater part devastated districts, seeds, pack-animals, machines, and labor, with the result that to-day the occupied parts of the East are looking forward to a harvest which, in accordance with the same principles of food distribution prevailing in Germany, places the supply of the inhabitants with cereals and potatoes on a safe footing. Furthermore, my administration, by systematically combating the epidemic diseases raging in the occupied parts, as cholera, dysentery, spotted fever, small-pox, has saved thousands and thousands of human lives, with the effect that to-day, in spite of the unavoidable miseries of war, the death rate in the occupied territories is hardly higher than under normal conditions before the war.

Still, I, too, would appreciate any assistance capable of further alleviating the lot of the innocent victims of the war to a greater extent than my administration with its own resources is able to do.

Accordingly as early as January 1915, my Government has in every way supported the efforts of the Rockefeller War Relief Commission to relieve the inhabitants who at that time were in special distress. However, the agreement entered upon by the Ambassador of the United States and the representative of my Government, in spring 1915, could unfortunately not be realized for reasons which were beyond my control and which you are well acquainted with.

If you, Mr. President, now offer the cooperation of the American people confidentially for the purpose of an effective relief, I thank you for this assistance and accept it. To-day, too, I am very willing to do everything in my power necessary for establishing the basis on which the assistance you offer may become effective. In my opinion, the manner in which this must be done is prescribed by circumstances. According to the principles of international law, which were generally recognized before the war, the charitable contributions you wish to direct to the inhabitants of the occupied territories belong to the articles of relative contraband, the transmission of which on neutral ships a warring power has the right to prevent only as far as these articles are destined for the armed forces of another warring state. As in the past, my Government is ready to give a guarantee that the contributions which American charity wishes to transmit to the inhabitants of the occupied territories will be of benefit only to these inhabitants. If in spite of such guarantees, a power which is in state of war with Germany continues to prevent American citizens from exercising their unobjectionable rights or to base its permission on conditions which have no foundation in the principles of international law and from the start are unacceptable to my Government, I must refuse to assume the responsibility for such an outcome.

In expressing to you, Mr. President, my sincere appreciation of your generous intentions, I avail myself of this opportunity to extend to you the assurances of my highest consideration.

Wilhelm I. R.

V. Jagow

  1. See letter from the President of July 20 and footnote 1 thereto, ante, p. 903.