File No. 763.72112/9

The Insurance Company of North America to the Secretary of State

Dear Sir: This company is, and has been, for more than a century, engaged in writing marine insurance on imports to and exports from the United States, and owing to the present condition of warfare now existing in Europe, we would ask you for advices on the following points:

Any information which your Department may be in a position to give us as to what is regarded as actual contraband of war; what kind of merchandise is regarded as conditional contraband; what kind of merchandise is not liable to seizure at all.

Any information which your Department may be able to give us regarding rights of belligerents to capture neutral property; what property may be considered to be neutral, and when such property ceases to become neutral; in fact, any information that your Department can give us, which will enable us to properly compute rates of marine insurance against risks of war, will be of great advantage, not only to us, but to thousands of importers and exporters in the United States, who depend on us for protection against the risks incident to capture and detention.

Yours [etc.]

Benjamin Rush
President
[Page 273]

The Secretary of State to the Insurance Company of North America

Gentlemen: The Department acknowledges the receipt of your letter of the 3d instant in which you ask to be informed by the Department “as to what is regarded as actual contraband of war, what kind of merchandise is provisional contraband, and what kind is not liable to seizure at all.” This and the other information solicited in your letter you state is to enable your company to compute properly rates of marine insurance against the risks of war.

The Department appreciates the importance of the subject, in view of the state of war which exists between certain of the European governments and the effect of the European disturbances upon American commerce, but the Department believes that you will, upon second thought, agree with it that it is not advisable or judicious for the Department to attempt to furnish you with a statement of the rules of international law on the several points submitted in your letter, upon which statement by the Department your rates of insurance are presumably to be based. The questions of contraband of war and maritime commerce during a state of war are subject to so many qualifications and exceptions that the Department thinks you had best consult private counsel, who will be able to find the matter discussed at length in many of the standard works on international law, which works, if not available in the private libraries of counsel, will doubtless be found in any large public library.

I am [etc.]

For the Secretary of State:
Robert Lansing
Counselor