Mr. Hill to Mr. Choate.

No. 895.]

Sir: Referring to previous correspondence, and particularly to the Department’s No. 735, of September 30, 1901, and to your Nos. 687 and 692, of October 19 and 28, 1901, touching the reported release on parole of certain prisoners at Ceylon and their return to their homes in Germany, and the refusal of the British Government to consider applications for release other than those in which the prisoners are certified to be seriously ill, I have now to inclose a further dispatch from Consul Morey at Colombo in which, adverting again to the release of the four German prisoners, he reported the grave condition of health of one of the American prisoners, F. M. Hearn.

The Department leaves it to your discretion whether, in view of the facts already in your possession and of the consul’s present report of the illness of one of the American prisoners, you will again bring the matter to the attention of His Majesty’s Government.

I am, etc.,

David J. Hill,
Acting Secretary.
[Inclosure.]

Mr. Morey to Mr. Hill.

No. 618.]

Sir: Department instructions No. 251, dated November 11, 1901, regarding liberated German prisoners of war, have been received, and I have to further report on the subject.

I note that the British Government allows that prisoners of war, Lavino and Walkie, [Page 489] referred to in my letter No. 599 of August 27 last, were released for special reasons, and I am assured that the same was the case with respect to John Winburg or Wynburg, another German liberated last year.

Thus it appears that the said three men were not ill, neither was Lieut. Thilo Von Trother, whom I mentioned in my letter to Ambassador Choate, and to the Department in my No. 611 of November 20, 1901. Accordingly, so far as I can learn, four prisoners of war of German nationality have been liberated here when not seriously ill.

Since the liberation of the four men aforesaid, F. M. Hearn, one of the Americans referred to in my letter No. 599 of August 27, 1901, has been for three months seriously ill in the Colombo General Hospital, of enteric fever, from which he is now convalescing. The first physician of the hospital (Dr. H. M. Fernando) is of opinion that this man’s recovery will be permanent, and that his life will not be endangered by a continuation of his local captivity. I, however, with all due respect for Dr. Fernando’s judgment, think differently, and believe that if Hearn is returned to the prisoners’ camp he will be again ill and probably die, for he is very feeble constitutionally.

I am, etc.,

W. Morey, Consul.