Mr. Conger to Mr. Hay.

No. 950.]

Sir: I have the honor to inclose herewith copies of correspondence with Consul Wilcox, of Hankow, in regard to the applications of Messrs. Kuhl and Snyder, American missionaries, for permission to reside and travel in Thibet.

The correspondence is self-explanatory. I may possibly be exercising an excess of caution in declining to urge their request upon the Chinese Government; but the present time does not seem to me to be opportune, and I am unwilling that our people shall take any undue risks by traveling in Thibet.

I have, etc.,

E. H. Conger.
[Inclosure 1.]

Mr. Wilcox to Mr. Conger.

Sir: I had the honor to forward applications for passports for Messrs. Ruhl and Snyder to return to their mission in eastern Thibet. I received their passports Nos. 367 and 365, but while they give them permission to travel in Hupeh, Szechuen, and Kansuh, they do not permit them to travel in Thibet.

[Page 227]

They desire to leave here by April 5. I would therefore inquire if a special permit can not be granted to them (separately) to return to their mission in Thibet?

Awaiting your early reply, I have, etc.,

L. S. Wilcox, Consul.
[Inclosure 2.]

Mr. Conger to Mr. Wilcox.

Sir: Referring to your dispatch dated the 5th instant, in regard to passports of Messrs. Ruhl and Snyder, requesting permission to return to their mission in Thibet, I have to say that in returning these passports to the legation the Foreign office said:

“As to the mention of Thibet in your note, the Western tribes are wild and fierce in character and constantly insult and annoy strangers and people from a distance, so that it will be difficult to satisfactorily arrange for safe protection. If we cause the people of various countries to run into danger and any remissness should occur it would be impossible to avoid injuries to good feeling. For several years our board has warned against this, of which there is record.”

The treaty right to travel in Thibet is doubtful. But in any event I do not believe it wise at the present time to urge the point or add to the difficulties of the Chinese Government in the protection of foreigners and the maintenance of order. As it is evidently reluctant to grant permission lest some accident occur, I deem it best to respect its wishes. I am therefore constrained to advise Messrs. Ruhl and Snyder to postpone their contemplated journey to Thibet until a more favorable occasion.

I am, etc.,

E. H. Conger.