694.001/7–2750

Memorandum by the Consultant to the Secretary (Dulles) to the Secretary of State

top secret

I attach a draft of prospective articles on “International Peace and Security” which might be used in a treaty with Japan. They are designed to give, in a form as inoffensive as possible to the Japanese, the broad power in the United States to place military forces where-ever in Japan the United States may determine to be desirable from the standpoint of maintenance of international peace and security in the Japan area.

This draft has now been cleared by the various Department officials who would be interested and is now given to you for the purpose of transmission to the Department of Defense for its study.

I would suggest transmission by you to Secretary Johnson, and in view of the talks which Secretary Johnson and I have had about the [Page 1260] subject both in Tokyo and in Washington, I might concurrently want to say a personal word to Secretary Johnson about it.

[Attachment]

International Peace and Security

article i

As a prospective member of the United Nations, Japan accepts in advance the obligation to act in accordance with the principles of Article 2 of the Charter of the United Nations for the maintenance of international peace and security, and the other Parties as members of the United Nations undertake reciprocally to be guided by those same principles in their relations with Japan.

article ii

In order further to contribute to the establishment and maintenance in the Japan area of conditions conducive to international peace and security in accordance with the principles of the Charter of the United Nations1 and subject to the transfer of this responsibility to the United Nations under the conditions foreseen in Article IV, Japan requests and the United States agrees that it will provide such armed forces on behalf of the Treaty Powers, and the Japanese Government on its part shall provide such assistance and facilities, including rights of passage, as may be determined by the United States in consultation with the Japanese Government. The Treaty Powers other than the United States that are willing to contribute to such forces for the above purposes may do so by agreement with the United States. The forces furnished by the United States or other Treaty Powers shall not have any responsibility or authority to intervene in the internal affairs of Japan.

article iii

During the period this chapter2 is in effect, Japan will not permit another Power to have military facilities in Japan except in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter or Article 43 of the Charter of the United Nations.

[Page 1261]

article iv

The provisions of this Chapter shall remain in effect until Japan has been admitted to the United Nations and until the coming into force of such special agreements referred to in Article 43 of the Charter as, in the opinion of those Treaty Powers providing forces under the terms of Article II, will enable the Security Council to exercise its responsibilities under Article 42 of the Charter for the maintenance of international peace and security in the Japan area and to end irresponsible militarism in the world.3

(Note: It is contemplated that there shall be concluded, effective with the coming into force of the present Treaty, an agreement between the United States and Japan, to which any other Parties providing forces under Article II may adhere, governing the stationing and employment of the forces provided under Article II, including the manner in which the signatory powers shall share the financial burden of the armed forces and the assistance and facilities provided under that Article.)

  1. Handwritten in the margin for insertion at this point is the phrase and having regard for the fact that irresponsible militarism is not yet ended in the world,”.

    In a memorandum of July 28 to the Secretary, Mr. Dulles said in part that the reference to “‘irresponsible militarism’” formerly in Article IV had been shifted to Article II at the suggestion of Ambassador Jessup. (694.001/7–2750)

  2. The four articles together were meant to be one chapter of a draft treaty.
  3. In the file copy the words “and to end irresponsible militarism in the world” have been crossed out and a period placed after “area.” In a memorandum of July 27 to Mr. Dulles, Ambassador Jessup had in part recommended this change: “The criterion suggested would imply that this Chapter will remain in force until the millennium.” (Lot 54D423)