Mr. Denby to Mr. Sherman.

No. 2713.]

Sir: In my dispatch No. 2705, of the 11th instant, I transmitted a copy of a communication which was sent by me to the Tsung-li Yamên, demanding the dismissal from office of the magistrate, Liu Yan-Kwang, whom the governor of Kiangsu had promised should be dismissed on account of his neglect of duty at the time of the occurrence of the riot at Kiang Yin.

I have the honor to inclose a translation of the Yamên’s answer, from which it will be seen that the matter has been referred to the governor for his report thereon.

I have, etc.,

Charles Denby.
[Inclosure in No. 2713.]

The Tsung-li Yamên to Mr. Denby.

Your Excellency: We have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your excellency’s note in regard to the investigation of the Kiang-yin riot last year, and the dismissal from office of the magistrate, Liu [Page 101] Yan-Kwang; that eight months have elapsed, and the consul addressed the governor of Kiangsu, asking that he be dismissed at once, but the governor refused to accede to the demand.

Your excellency requests the Yamên to issue orders to the governor of Kiangsu that the magistrate, Liu, be immediately dismissed from office, etc.

We have the honor to state that, in regard to this case, last year perpetrators of the crime were punished, and indemnity for losses sustained was paid and the matter settled—the money being paid to the United States consul, who, at the time of receiving it, made not the slightest objection.

We transmitted to your excellency on the 9th September, 1896, a report on this case from the minister superintendent of southern trades, stating that it had been closed. This is on record.

Now, having received your excellency’s note under acknowledgment, we have the honor to state that we have looked through the records of this case in the Yamên, but can not find any reference to the question of the dismissal from office of Magistrate Liu.

We find it, therefore, difficult from our archives to guess or form an opinion as to how the question arose, whether or not it was talked of between the taotai and consul, or whether or not it was presented clearly before the governor. The Yamên has written to the governor of Kiangsu, presenting your excellency’s statements, and requested an investigation to be made.

In the meantime, we send this note for your excellency’s information.

Cards of ministers, with compliments.