406. Telegram 201 From the Embassy in Haiti to the Department of State1

201. Subject: Duvalier Pardons 26 Political Prisoners.

1. Begin unclassified. Local media announced over weekend that President Jean-Claude Duvalier had granted full pardon to 26 political prisoners. Newspaper Panorama said pardoning reaffirmed Duvalier’s policy of détente and reconciliation, which has assured true peace and economic gains. The only prominent person among the 26 is Jean Bernadel, former Deputy Director of the Royal Bank of Canada’s branch in Haiti.

2. The pardoning order, dated Jan. 22 (the fourth anniversary of Duvalier’s public selection by his father, Dr. Francois Duvalier, to succeed him as President) observed that quote on the occasion of the commemoration of great historic dates, it is proper to exalt the most generous concepts of the nation. Considering that the right of pardon, one of the essential attributes of the Chief of State, is a mode of exercising this generosity; considering that in view of giving the historic date of Jan. 22, 1975 this solemn significance, the Chief of State has decided to [Page 1049]grant clemency in favor of certain persons condemned for political reasons. End quote.

3. The names of the released prisoners, as printed in Le Nouvelliste dated January 25–26, are:

Serge Benoit

Beauvois Celamy

Jean-Charles Harry

Wilson J. Virgelin

Jeannot Chery

St.-Louis Voltaire

Rodrique Zamor

Lumenes Olivier

Jean Bernadel

Dalus Joseph

Roosevelt Milord

Joseph Rene Gelin

Jacques Duvert

Justin Alexis

Rene Duverger

Nestor Elie

Mertyle Olivier

Guillaume Fraxe

Wilson Hais

Joseph Jean

Dorlean Exil

Alfred Rodrigue

Adrien Francois

Saurel Labissiere

Francisque Eric

Felix Bien-Aime

End unclassified—begin confidential.

4. In addition to Bernadel, who was arrested in Aug. 1972 for his alleged role in a subversive plot (PauP 1415 of July 24, 1974), an initial file check indicates that only two, perhaps three, of the released prisoners were known to this post:

A. J. Virgelin Wilson (our records give Wilson as family name) was an enlisted man in Coast Guard believed to have been arrested in or before 1969 for alleged Communist activities.

B. Jacques Duvert was arrested on Feb. 10, 1969 for alleged Communist activities.

C. “Guillaume Fraxe” possibly could be Dr. Fritz Guillaume, who was listed as being member central committee of outlawed Partie Unifie Communiste D’Haiti (PUCH).

5. Panorama editorial on subject, despite text of pardon, stated that released prisoners were both political and common law. If true, this might explain why many names are unknown. We are seeking to elicit further information on released political prisoners.

[Page 1050]

6. Aside from 12 political prisoners released in Jan. 1973 in exchange for kidnapped U.S. Ambassador Knox, last public announcements of pardons were of 72 prisoners on Dec. 19, 1972 and of 89 prisoners on Nov. 28, 1972.

7. Comment: The pardon reflects government’s growing self-confidence and willingness to take steps that implicitly repudiate harsh methods of Duvalier Pere. At time of revived congressional interest in human rights observance by governments receiving U.S. economic assistance, pardon is helpful move. We believe decision is responsive to quiet talks Ambassador has had on this subject over past several months with Foreign Minister Brutus, who has shown himself consistently sensitive to, and concerned to correct, Haiti’s “image” problem in U.S. Moreover, President Duvalier was usefully made aware of congressional interest in political prisoner issue during visits to Haiti in 1974 of Senators Pell and Brooke. Latter, in his report to Appropriations Committee, referred to issue as major unresolved problem and citen [certain] consideration being given to amnesty for political prisoners. As Department aware, President Duvalier ordered Brooke report to be circulated to all GOH cabinet members.

8. Action requested: Since Bernadel was one of those about whom Inouye committee requested information following hearings July 23, 1974, Dept. will wish to inform committee of his release. Request that Senator Brooke also be informed of government’s action.

Isham
  1. Summary: Noting that the Haitian Government had pardoned 26 political prisoners, the Embassy concluded that Ambassador Isham’s quiet representations to Haitian officials on the subject of human rights were having a positive effect.

    Source: National Archives, RG 59, Central Foreign Policy File, D750031–0603. Confidential; Priority. Repeated to Kingston and Santo Domingo. All brackets are in the original except “[certain]”, added for clarity. In telegram 160347 to Port-au-Prince, July 24, 1974, the Department transmitted Senator Inouye’s request for information on the whereabouts and legal status of Jean Bernardel, one of the prisoners whose pardon by Duvalier was reported in this telegram. (Ibid., D740200–0532) In telegram 1415 from Port-au-Prince, July 25, 1974, the Embassy replied that Bernadel had been arrested in August 1972 in connection with an alleged plot against the Haitian Government and was presumed to be in prison. (Ibid., D740201–1219) In telegram 225 from Port-au-Prince, January 29, the Embassy reported that the background of the other 25 released prisoners remained unclear and that some of them might have been common criminals. (Ibid., D750033–0849)