302. Briefing Paper for President Nixon1
MEETING WITH ISMAIL FAHMI, SPECIAL EGYPTIAN EMISSARY
Wednesday, October 31, 1973
3:00 p.m. (45 minutes)
The Oval Office
From: Henry A. Kissinger
To summarize our effort to consolidate the Middle East ceasefire and to persuade Egypt to have confidence in US determination to engage actively in Mid-East peace negotiations and to enter those negotiations without preconditions.
II. Background, Participants, Press Plan
A. Background: President Sadat sent Fahmi to Washington for an exchange of views on consolidating the Egyptian-Israeli ceasefire and on peace negotiations in order to prepare the way for my talks in Cairo November 6. Fahmi is normally Minister of Tourism but has been Acting Foreign Minister while Foreign Minister Zayyat was at the UN during the war.
Most of my talks with Fahmi have concentrated on a package to consolidate the ceasefire. It would be useful for you to summarize this, and it is detailed in your talking points below. We put this proposal to the Israelis so that Mrs. Meir would have it before her departure.
Beyond summarizing the ceasefire package, I would suggest that you focus on what the US can and cannot do in the peace negotiations.
The problem we face with the Egyptians is the familiar one of persuading them to negotiate seriously on the terms of a peace agreement without insisting that we deliver in advance of negotiations the total Egyptian package.
On the other side, a principal Israeli request is to give them a chance to negotiate some of the terms themselves. When you talk with [Page 799]Mrs. Meir, you will want to be in a position to say that we have done nothing to foreclose that opportunity even though we cannot be optimistic that peace can be achieved if they maintain that position.
Given these two positions, it is likely that the peace negotiations will deadlock very quickly. Our strategy will be to try to segment the negotiations so attention can be focussed in the early stages on a first step that—difficult as it may be—might realistically be taken in the next few weeks while terms of a final settlement are still being negotiated.
If we are to succeed in this course, we will have to develop Egyptian confidence without going into too much detail.
One other issue is our desire to have Sadat, once the ceasefire is consolidated, urge Faisal to relax the oil boycott when negotiations begin.
B. Participants: Egyptian Emissary Ismail Fahmi accompanied perhaps by Ambassador Abdallah El Erian (Egyptian ambassador to Paris) and Ahmed Khalil, head of the Egyptian Interests Section in Washington. I will sit in on the US side.
C. Press Plan: Press photo opportunity at the beginning. Press Secretary to brief in very general terms.
III. Talking Points
A. I understand you (Fahmi) and Secretary Kissinger are working on a proposal for consolidating the ceasefire. As I understand it the main points are:
—The UN would assure that only non-military shipments reach the Egyptian Third Army when Israeli troops pull back.
—Israeli troops would move back to the October 22 ceasefire line. Prisoners of war would be released immediately.
—The Egyptian naval blockade at the mouth of the Red Sea would be raised.
B. It is important to consolidate the ceasefire, but it will be even more important to establish momentum in the peace negotiations.
C. The US will support those negotiations actively. I want you to understand what we can and cannot do.
—We can help devise a negotiating process that has at least a reasonable chance of succeeding. This may require that the negotiations be broken down into manageable units and steps. Patience will be required.
—We will use our influence with Israel. The convening of a peace conference will provide a framework. But we will need realistic proposals that have some chance of being agreed.
—In short, we have promised to engage in a process with good faith. We want the closest possible cooperation with Egypt.[Page 800]
D. Egypt has an interest in urging the oil producers to relax their boycott. The US will find it difficult to sustain the kind of role that will be required under threat of prolonged boycott.
- Source: National Archives, Nixon Presidential Materials, NSC Files, Box 610, Country Files, Middle East, Israel, Vol. 12, March–October 1973. Secret; Nodis. The paper is attached to an October 30 transmittal memorandum from Saunders to Scowcroft that reads: “This afternoon before coming back to my office I talked with Secretary Kissinger about his talks with Fahmi today and asked him what he wanted the President to do tomorrow. The attached talker is based on that conversation. Recommendation: That you send the attached to the President tonight.”↩