851B.20/278

The French Ambassador (Henry-Haye) to the Secretary of State

[Translation]

The Ambassador of France in the United States presents his compliments to His Excellency the Secretary of State and, acting on instructions from his Government, has the honor to forward to him herewith, for purposes of information, a copy of the note which was [Page 640] transmitted directly to Mr. Samuel Reber by Admiral Robert, High Commissioner in the West Indies.

Mr. Henry-Haye is happy to take this occasion to renew [etc.]

[Enclosure—Translation]

The French High Commissioner in the French West Indies (Robert) to Mr. Samuel Reber, Representative of the Department of State in Martinique

1.
The French Government has studied the proposals made in the American memorandum of May 23.3
2.
It draws therefrom a more accurate understanding of the situation, particularly with regard to the regularization of the relations existing between the French Government and its representative in the West Indies, Admiral Robert.
3.
It has given the latter all necessary instructions to proceed with the American negotiators to an examination of the suggestions presented in the memorandum of May 23 and replied to the questions posed therein.
4.
With respect to the utilization of the merchant ships, the French Government cannot agree to the American proposal providing for their chartering to a company to be established in a neutral South American country. Such a solution would be in contradiction to the obligations entailed on it by the armistice conventions and, on that account, cannot be considered. The French Government, since the armistice, has not chartered merchant ships to another party except with the agreement of all the belligerents.
5.
The French Government is still compelled to maintain its proposal of May 13 for the immobilization of merchant ships in West Indian waters, except those the movements of which are strictly necessary to carry on the economic life of the islands and indispensable relations with French North Africa, that is: the Saint-Domingue, the Guadeloupe, the Duc d’Aumale, together with the Angoulême, the Merope, the Indiana, the Mont Everest and, if possible an oil tanker, the Oregon on the one hand and the Sagittaire on the other.
6.
The French Government hopes that this question of merchant tonnage, of a relatively low amount if compared with the present amounts being built or destroyed in the world, will not create any obstacle to the conclusion of an agreement which should make possible, with respect for French sovereignty and neutrality, a settlement of the problems arising in the French possessions in the Western Hemisphere from the war.
  1. Not found in Department files. Apparently this was a note presented at Fort-de-France by Admiral Hoover to Admiral Robert.