The Belgian Minister to the Secretary of State.

[Memorandum.]

The German firms of Baer, sr., and E. Weber, and the Belgian firm of El Oriente filed five years ago with the United States Government a request for the refunding of some very important sums of money, which after having been seized upon by the Philippine insurgents were afterwards retaken by the American troops.

According to a report which the Belgian minister heard, the War Department, after ordering an inquiry into the case by a commission in the Philippine Islands, refused to take a final decision itself and sent the matter over to the State Department for a final award.

Baron Moncheur begs to recommend this case to the kind attention of Judge Penfield.

He mentions especially:

(a)
The argument which M. Guislain, Belgian consul-general at Manila, addressed to Governor-General Wright, January 28, 1904.
(b)
The letter from the same consul-general to Governor-General Wright, November 4, 1904, and in which he makes sundry observations on the report of the committee appointed to make a further inquiry into the Saturnus case.

Copies of these documents have been handed by Baron Moncheur to Judge Magoon and must accordingly be inclosed in the brief.