751G.00/9–2954: Telegram
The Acting Secretary of State to the Embassy in Vietnam1
1328. Paris pass Heath. Saigon’s 1269 rptd Paris 438.2 In half hour conversation with General Ely3 Kidder outlined contents ref telegram which Ely believes may offer basis for compromise with Binh Xuyen on Ministry of Interior.
He appears sincerely convinced necessity give Diem Govt fair chance prove self. Explained it his personal view if Diem Government fails object having Bao Dai send Buu Loc Vietnam would be for latter have delegation powers choose successor to Diem rather than form government himself.
Re statement in press here by Vietnamese Ambassador regarding withdrawal French Expeditionary Corps by March 1956 Ely said this would necessitate planning withdrawal forces very shortly. This he [Page 2112] believes would be dangerous as would undermine confidence of people free Vietnam.
Ely inquired into reason for difference between Ambassador Saigon and Daridan and speculated that Daridan is so opposed Diem that it colors his views, nevertheless Ely says Daridan will have to follow instructions and go along with agreed decision France and US support Diem government.
Ely also speculated on possibility, in case failure Diem Government, Bao Dai might return Vietnam take over power himself, as last chance. He pointed out Bao Dai has always felt constrained by French but with complete independence of action he might prove more effective than previously.
In reply Ely’s question Kidder expressed view it would be preferable for him and Ambassador Heath see Bao Dai separately. A joint démarche could be made subsequently if for any reason desirable.
Young saw Ely shortly thereafter who agreed desirability give Diem chance and advisability separate approaches Bao Dai. Also felt Hinh only available choice Chief Staff but should be limited to military matters.