851G.00/9–1147: Telegram
The Consul at Saigon (Reed) to the Secretary of State
291. Most apt comment Bollaert’s speech is “one begins to see what French Union will be but one does not see a solution to the conflict”. General comment is to effect political setup envisaged in speech is practicable and in many ways fair both to natives and French but it falls far short of independence and contains parts which are seemingly contrary to assertion that Union of three Kys is internal problem; statement that French offer must be accepted in entirety or not at all and that this is last appeal sound like threats. In summary speech presents no solution and as there is no mention armistice, French military plan will go into effect unless Bao Dai comes forward “if my presence is desired by the people”. It would be embarrassing for French if Ho accepted cooperate along lines of speech but most people think this unlikely and terms of speech appear preclude any dealings with Ho alone. More change [chance] Bao Dai accepting what appears to be return to virtual pre-war status under new guise but if does so he will believe [belie] his vaunted desire achieve independence for his people.
Please pass Paris.