740.00119 EW/2–247

The Minister for Foreign Affairs of the Soviet Union ( Molotov ) to the Secretary of State 11

[Translation]

On January 16 of this year I received a letter from the Minister of Foreign Affairs of China, Mr. Wang Shih-chieh in which is set forth the point of view of the Chinese Government on questions of procedure in connection with the peace settlement for Germany and Austria. It is understood that you received a similar letter.

As will be seen from the attached draft of my reply, the Soviet Government does not consider it possible to agree with the point of view set forth in the cited letter from Mr. Wang Shih-chieh since this point of view does not correspond to the decision of the Berlin Conference. Before sending my reply, I consider it necessary to ascertain the viewpoint of the members of the Council of Foreign Ministers concerning this question.

I would be grateful to you if you would be so kind as to inform me if you agree with the basic theses of my attached reply to Mr. Wang Shih-chieh or if you have any observations.12

At the same time, I am sending a similar message to Mr. Bevin and Mr. Bidault.

[Enclosure]

The Minister for Foreign Affairs of the Soviet Union ( Molotov ) to the Chinese Foreign Minister ( Wang )

[Translation]

In reply to your communication, received in Moscow on January 16 of this year, with regard to the procedure in connection with the peace settlement for Germany, I consider it necessary again to set forth the position of the Soviet Government concerning this question.

In the Berlin decisions, particularly in the section concerning the establishment of the Council of Foreign Ministers,13 are contained provisions relating to the order of preparation of the peace settlement [Page 149] for Germany. From these decisions it is clear that, for the solution of this problem, the Council will be composed of members representing those States which signed the conditions of the capitulation dictated to Germany.

In regard to the convocation of the Conference for the consideration of the draft peace treaty with Germany, clause “B”, article 3 of the section concerning “the establishment of the Council of Foreign Ministers” leaves no doubt that the convocation of the said Conference must be made by the Council of Ministers composed of those who signed the conditions of the capitulation with the given enemy State. It appears to be self-evident that this clause embraces such questions as the determination of the participants in the forthcoming Peace Conference concerning Germany as well as the determination of the procedure for invitations to this Conference. It is also necessary to state that the Government of a country not participating in the preparation of the peace treaty would find itself in a difficult situation with regard to the determination of questions relating to the convocation of the Peace Conference, in as much as the date and other questions of the convocation of such Conference are indissolubly linked with the termination of the preparation for the peace settlement.

With regard to the preparation of the treaty with Austria the Council of Foreign Ministers, meeting in New York, acted, as is entirely natural, in a manner similar to the preparation of the other treaties.

As regards the agenda of the forthcoming session of the Council of Foreign Ministers in Moscow, it was determined by the Council on December 12, 1946 in the form in which it was published in the press.

  1. This message was transmitted to the Secretary of State by the Soviet Chargé in Washington on February 2, 1947.
  2. The Secretary of State replied to this message by sending to Foreign Minister Molotov the text of the Secretary’s message of February 5 to Chinese Foreign Minister Wang, p. 153. The Secretary’s reply to Molotov was contained in a note of February 5 to the Soviet Chargé, not printed (740.00119 EW/2–247).
  3. See Section II of the Report on the Tripartite Conference of Berlin, August 2, 1945, Foreign Relations, The Conference of Berlin (The Potsdam Conference), 1945, vol. ii, pp. 15001501.