856E.00/2–1446: Telegram
The Consul General at Batavia (Foote) to the Secretary of State53
[Received February 15—9:50 a.m.]
53. In private talk at Sharir’s home tonight he expressed no hope whatever for success of negotiations. He said that if he accepted Dutch proposals he would be let out at once; that they provide only for Dutch domination; liquidation of the Republic of Indonesia; gave new names to old things and that the word “commonwealth” as used therein has no meaning. He added Indonesia has no interest in proposed Kingdom cabinet and parliament but would accept status similar to Australia’s in British Empire. He concluded saying Dutch proposals so unacceptable as a whole that it is impossible now to discuss details.
My opinion is Sharir is searching for arguments to present to Indonesians in support of agreement. In fact he asked Clark Kerr and Van Mook for such and he appeared anxious learn our reactions to Dutch proposal. On other hand I believe Clark Kerr’s rank and prestige gave Indonesians more self-confidence and caused them believe British seeking desperately solve problem. Belief that British will [Page 811] not fight and Dutch unable do so may cause Indonesians stiffen attitude and increase demands. Sharir may also hope USA in defense its trade and industries may bring some pressure on Dutch. Situation is still confused to evaluate remarks or predict actions.
- Repeated by the Department as telegram 115, February 16, 4 p.m., to The Hague.↩