611.3131/176

The Minister in Venezuela (Nicholson) to the Secretary of State

No. 944

Sir: I have the honor to confirm my telegram no. 18 of February 25, 1938, 5 p.m., and to enclose a copy with English translation of the Memorandum from the Minister of Hacienda referred to therein. Dr. Ramon Eduardo Tello, who delivered the Memorandum to the Legation, stated that the Venezuelan Government would have no objection to the publication of the second announcement in Washington at the earliest possible moment.

Respectfully yours,

Meredith Nicholson
[Enclosure—Translation]

The Venezuelan Ministry of Hacienda to the American Legation

Memorandum

In the memorandum5 of the Legation of the United States of America, dated the fourth instant, it is stated anew that the criterion which should regulate the concessions of advantages is the consideration [Page 961] of whether a country is the principal supplier in a category of products imported by the other country. It is obvious that such a criterion, while it may be desirable to the United States by reason of its enormous economic development which makes of it the principal supplier of many of the articles which we import, is very disadvantageous for a country of modest economic development like Venezuela which cannot aspire to the position of chief supplier of the American market in any of the products which make up its exportation.

The admission of this criterion would regularize the situation adverse to Venezuela and would make impossible the obtaining of any advantage needed for Venezuelan products in compensation for the advantages which would be granted to the majority of the American products.

In the preliminary conversations only the general provisions of the agreement were discussed, but when any reference was made to the lists of products which would be annexed to articles I and II of the draft, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs expressed the view that the requests for advantages by the one and the other country should be based on the approximate calculations of the equivalents of values represented by those advantages, so that there might be equality and effective reciprocity in the concessions granted. This consideration of the equivalence of the advantages was incorporated in articles I and II of the draft agreement presented by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

With respect to the list of products on which the American Government hopes for concessions, the list will not be published by the Government of Venezuela until the latter has reached entire agreement with the Government of the United States on the concessions to grant.

  1. Not found in Department files.