611.3731/546

The Ambassador in Cuba ( Caffery ) to the Secretary of State

No. 46

Sir: With reference to previous correspondence concerning negotiations for a revision of our reciprocity treaty with Cuba, I have the honor to transmit herewith a tentative draft of certain of the general provisions to be included in the treaty, prepared by our technical advisers. I should appreciate receiving the Department’s instructions with respect to the enclosed draft articles at an early date.

Respectfully yours,

Jefferson Caffery
[Page 113]
[Enclosure]

Proposed General Provisions for the New Commercial Convention Between the United States and Cuba

Article I

During the term of this convention, all articles of merchandise being the product of the soil or industry of the United States which are now imported into the Republic of Cuba free of duty, and all articles of merchandise being the product of the soil or industry of the Republic of Cuba which are now imported into the United States free of duty, shall continue to be so admitted by the respective countries free of duty (except as provided in Article . . of this convention).

Article II

During the term of this convention, the articles of merchandise specified in Schedule 1 annexed to this convention, being the product of the soil or industry of the Republic of Cuba, imported into the United States shall be admitted under the rates of duty and classifications and shall enjoy the preferences therein specified.

During the term of this convention, the articles of merchandise specified in Schedule 2 annexed to this convention, being the product of the soil or industry of the United States, its territories and possessions, imported into the Republic of Cuba, shall be admitted under the rates of duty and classification and shall enjoy the preferences therein specified.

The rates of duty specified in Schedules 1 and 2, whether ad valorem or specific, are understood to be maximum rates of duty, and may not be increased during the life of this convention except as hereinafter provided.

The percentages of preference specified as against the rates of duty on like articles imported from other countries, as in Schedules 1 and 2, are understood to be minimum percentages and may not be decreased during the life of this convention.

The term “like articles”, as used in this connection, shall be taken to mean articles similar in material, texture, quality or uses to which applied.

In any subsequent revision of the tariffs of the respective countries the minimum amount of the preferences accorded to each other at the time this convention enters into force may not be decreased during the life of this convention.

In the case of articles subject to specific duties the minimum value of the preferential is understood to mean the difference between the rates of duty established in Schedules 1 and 2 and the general rates [Page 114] of duty in effect at the time this convention enters into force. In any subsequent reduction of the general rate, this amount must be deducted from the proposed new general rate to arrive at the new rate on any product specified in Schedules 1 and 2.

In the case of articles subject to ad valorem duties, the minimum value of the preferential is understood to mean the amount of the difference between the general ad valorem rates of duty in effect at the time this convention enters into force and the ad valorem rates established in Schedules 1 and 2.

In any subsequent revision of the tariffs of the respective countries the minimum amount of the preferences accorded to each other at the time this convention enters into force may not be decreased during the life of this convention.

Article III

With respect to articles not specified in Schedules 1 and 2, duties may be increased or decreased by the respective countries but such changes shall not become operative until at least 30 days after public notice thereof in the usual official manner. The provisions of this paragraph do not apply to administrative orders imposing antidumping duties, relating to sanitation or public safety, or giving effect to judicial or customs courts decisions.

However, the percentages of preference of articles not specified in Schedules 1 and 2 as now provided in the Commercial Convention of December 11, 1902 shall continue in force during the term of this convention, and the value thereof as described in Paragraphs 6 and 7 of Article II shall not be decreased.

Rates of duty on articles specified in Schedules 1 and 2 may be increased to a maximum of 50% of these rates only by common agreement between the Presidents of the United States and Cuba on the advice of their respective Tariff Commissions.*

In the event that these rates are increased, the value of the preferences must be proportionately increased.

The classifications specified in Schedules 1 and 2 may be changed only by common agreement between the Presidents of the United States and Cuba on the advice of their respective Tariff Commissions.

Article IV

Duties on articles imported into the United States from Cuba shall be paid in United States legal tender.

[Page 115]

Duties on articles imported into Cuba from the United States shall be paid in Cuban or United States legal tender,

Article V

All products of the soil or industry of either High Contracting Power after importation into the territory of the other Party shall be exempt from any national, federal, state, provincial or municipal taxes or charges other or higher than those payable on like articles of national origin.

All products of the soil or industry of one of the High Contracting Powers shall, on their importation into the territories of the other, be exempt from any internal taxes or charges whatsoever, other or higher than those in force on the day of the signature of this convention.

The High Contracting Parties bind themselves not to impose any export duties on any articles exported to the territories of the other.

The High Contracting Parties agree not to impose taxes or restrictions of any nature on the exportation of money or its kind other or higher than those in force on the day of the signature of this convention, insofar as such transactions relate to trade between the two countries.

In order to maintain the reciprocal advantages herein stipulated, the High Contracting Parties agree that in case any such advantage is in fact, or is threatened to be, substantially diminished or nullified by the importation of like articles of trade from a third country with benefit of depreciation of the currency of any such third country, of any bounty, or of any form of dumping such articles, imported directly from any such foreign country or otherwise, such articles shall be subject to a new or additional duty equal to the net amount of any such currency depreciation, bounty, or dumping practice.

Article VI

Insofar as rates and charges for transportation services within either country are imposed or controlled directly or indirectly by the respective Contracting Parties, goods which are the product of the [Page 116] soil or industry of one of the countries shall pay within the territory of the other rates and charges which are not discriminatory as compared with the rates and charges on like goods imported from a third country or of domestic origin transported under like circumstances and conditions.

Article VII

It is agreed that the High Contracting Parties will maintain consular invoice fees on a fixed basis not to exceed $5.00 each or on an ad valorem basis not to exceed 5% of the value at the point of origin of the shipment. In the event either Party maintains this charge on an ad valorem basis, it shall grant to the other a 50% preferential in such charge.

Article VIII

All questions arising with respect to the preservation of the respective rights and advantages accorded to either High Contracting Party under the provisions of this convention shall be submitted for settlement to the Board of Arbitration created as herein provided. The classification, appraisal and assessment of duties under Schedules 1 and 2 shall be accomplished, and protests and appeals relating thereto shall be settled in the ordinary procedure established by the laws, regulations and rules of the respective High Contracting Parties. In the event that either Contracting Party is dissatisfied with the result thereof, or has cause to believe that the procedure and decision relating to protests and appeals is unduly or unreasonably delayed,§ the Secretary of State of such country shall so notify the Secretary of State of the other country and request the creation of a Board of Arbitration to determine and settle the question at issue. The respective Secretaries of State shall thereupon each appoint one Arbitrator and if the two Arbitrators cannot agree they shall appoint a third. The decision of such Board of Arbitration shall be final and conclusive upon the Contracting Parties.

[Page 117]

The High Contracting Parties agree to furnish the Board with all means required for its investigation and report.

The expenses of the Board shall be paid by the two Governments in equal proportions.

  1. The American delegation at Habana desires a certain degree of flexibility in the treaty in order to meet readjustments in economic forces. These powers are in large measure already enjoyed by the Presidents of the respective Republics. [Footnote in the original.]
  2. The above wording is probably not adequate to safeguard the purposes we have in mind.

    Decree No. . . of . . . . . . . provided that Cuban consular fees were to be payable on the basis of Cuban gold. Prior to that date they were payable on the basis of either United States currency or Cuban gold. As a result of this decree, Cuban consular officers were instructed to increase Cuban consular fees by 30%. Representations by the American Embassy led to the recision of this order insofar as consular fees collected in the United States were concerned but it remained in effect with respect to countries other than the United States until the promulgation of Decree No. . . of . . . . . . . .

    It is further desired to prevent any possible adoption by Cuba of the Brazilian conversion system in the payment of duties. [Footnote in the original.]

  3. The American delegation is not unanimous as to this article because it is feared that the granting of the preferential on the consular fees might be interpreted as an admission by the Cuban Government that this fee is tantamount to an additional import duty. The treaties between Cuba and Spain (and other countries) bind the Cuban import duties on specified products so that this admission might justify a claim on the part of these countries for complete exemption from this charge on the commodities so bound.

    As an alternative to the above article the delegation recommends:

    “It is agreed that the High Contracting Parties will not impose consular invoice fees on an ad valorem basis in excess of 2½% of the value at the point of origin of the shipment.” [Footnote in the original.]

  4. The American delegation is not in accord as to the removal of causes owing to unreasonable delay and as to the elimination of the present formality of the decisions of the United States Court of Customs and Patent Appeals. [Footnote in the original.]