Paris Peace Conf. 184.01202/18

Captain W. R. Gherardi to the Commission to Negotiate Peace

No. 3

Subject: Political situation.

1.
There are forwarded with today’s translations Ebert’s speech at the opening of the National Convention and some of the press comments thereon.2 The interruptions by the various parties of the extreme right and of the left show their salient points of disagreement with the government.
2.
Reports today show very heavy attacks upon Erzberger (Head of German Armistice Commission) for his action in surrendering the merchant shipping and on other questions. His resignation is foreshadowed by some papers.
3.
Among the parties to the right there has in the past week been a growing agitation over questions affecting the retention of former provinces which may be split off from Germany. My observation is that the masses of the people are apathetic on these questions, but vitally interested in securing food and working conditions. The difficulties of the present government will be overwhelming if some practical method of relieving, at least in part, the present economic situation is not found.
4.
The verbatim statement of the Independent Socialists refusing to cooperate with the Majority Socialists is forwarded amongst the translations.3 The Independent Socialists have thereby constituted the opposition. They are as yet a small minority as shown by the vote for the constituent assembly. They are likely to develop as time goes on and people dissatisfied with the results obtained by the government join their ranks.
5.
The Independent Socialists are the active upholders of the proletariat against the bourgeoisie. There are some moderates in it [Page 8] who differ little from the Socialist party as it was before it assumed control of the government, but the radical wing goes as far as Spartacus and wants the overthrow of the government by any means in their power. I am sending Mr. Day to Weimar on Monday to talk to Haase, who is the present active leader of the moderate section of the Independent Socialists.
6.
A description of the workings of the Soldiers’ Councils and their political significance is in course of preparation and will be forwarded shortly; also an inquiry is being made as to the morale of the army on the eastern border who are acting against the Bolsheviki.
W. R. Gherardi
[Enclosure]

Translation from the “Deutsche Tageszeitung,” February 7, 1919

Ebert’s Opening Speech at the National Assembly

Ladies and Gentlemen: Through me the government of the Empire greets the constitutional assembly of the German Nation. I extend an especially hearty greeting to the ladies, who appear for the first [time?] as equals in the parliament of the Empire. The provisional government owes its authority to the Revolution; it will give it back to the National Assembly. (Applause) The German people rose in the Revolution against an antiquated and collapsing despotism. (Hissing on the right). As soon as the right of the German to self government is assured, then normal legal measures will return. Only by the broad road of counsel and law-making can we progress with the imperative changes in the field of economics and social reform, without the empire and its economic situation. Therefore the government greets in this assembly the highest and only sovereign in Germany. (Applause)

The day of Kings and Princes by the Grace of God has passed for all time. (Lively applause on the left, hissing right, repeated vigorous applause on the left, and a cry from the right “Wait and see”). We do not forbid any sentimental recollections, but as certainly as this National Assembly has a large republican majority, so certainly have the old God given dependencies been laid aside for ever. The German people are free, will remain free and will govern themselves throughout the future. (Cry from the Ind. Soc. “With Noske”) This freedom is the single consolation left to the German people, the only way, by which it can work itself out of the bloody swamp of war and defeat. We have lost the war. This fact is not a consequence of the Revolution. (Cry right “Oho!”, left “No, never”). Ladies and gentlemen, it was the Imperial Government of Prince Max of Baden which brought on the armistice, that rendered us defenceless. [Page 9] (Cry: Ludendorff did it) After the collapse of our allies, and in the face of the military and economic situation, they could do nothing else. (Very true!) The Revolution refuses the responsibility for the misery into which the German people has been thrust by the perverse policies of the old authorities and by the arrogance of the militarists. (Very true, Applause from the Socialists, contradiction from the right) Nor is it responsible for our serious food situation. (Very true. Remonstrance and cry; Soldier’s Councils). The fact that we have lost many hundreds of thousands of lives by the hunger blockade, that hundreds of thousands of men, women, children and the old people have been its victims, disproves the theory that without the Revolution our food supplies would have lasted. Defeat and lack of food supplies have delivered us into the hands of our enemies. But the war has also terribly exhausted our enemies as well. Out of their feeling of exhaustion arises their effort to exact an indemnity from the German people, if the thought of exploitation enters into the peace negotiations at all. These plans of revenge and oppression demand the sharpest protest, (lively and universal assent). The German people cannot be made the slaves of other countries for twenty, forty or sixty years. (Renewed applause). The frightful misfortune of the war for all Europe can only be made good by all the nations going hand-in-hand. (Applause). In view of the misery of the masses, the question of blame is comparatively of little importance. Nevertheless the German people is determined to call to account everyone who intentionally acted basely or is in any way guilty of anything against the state. But those who were themselves victims, victims of the war, victims of our former bondage, should not be punished. (Very true, from the Soc.)

Wherefore, by their own testimony, have our enemies fought? To destroy Kaiserism. That has now passed forever; the very fact of this Assembly is proof of that. They fought to destroy “Militarism”; it has been overthrown and lies in pieces never to rise again. (Cry from the Ind. Soc. “They will raise it again”). According to their solemn proclamations our enemies have been fighting for justice, freedom and a lasting peace. Nevertheless the conditions of the armistice have been hard to a degree unheard of before, and have been rigorously executed. Alsace is treated as French without further ado. The elections for the National Assembly which we proposed, have been hindered, contrary to law. (Cries of “Fie”), the Germans have been driven out of the land, (Renewed cries of “Fie”), and their possessions are confiscated. The occupied left bank of the Rhine is cut off from the rest of Germany. (Cry from the Ind. Soc. “Weimar will also be”). The clause in the armistice conditions that no public property be allowed to lie idle, is the object of great effort to increase [Page 10] its scope to the general financial enslavement of the German people. Long after we have become unable to take up arms again, our 800,000 prisoners of war are still retained, and threatened with moral collapse and are forced to hard labor. (Cries from the extreme left “We are still keeping the Russians”). From this act of despotism no spirit of conciliation speaks. (Assent) The conditions of the armistice were made to be imposed on the old Hohenzollern regime. How can the fact be justified that they continue to augment them, when the new Republic is using all its powers to meet its obligations?

We warn our enemies not to drive us to the utmost. Like General Winterfeldt, any German government might be forced to renounce any further cooperation in the peace negotiations, and throw the whole weight of the responsibility for the reorganization of the world on its enemies. Do not place us before the choice between hunger and disgrace. Even a socialistic government, and especially just such a government must hold fast to this policy: rather the worst privation than disinheritance. (Lively applause). If there were added to the millions who have lost everything in the war and have nothing more to lose, those who feel that Germany has nothing more to lose, the tactics of despair would irresistibly succeed.

Germany laid down her arms trusting in President Wilson’s principles. Let them now give us the Wilson peace to which we lay claim (Applause). Our free and popular republic, the whole German people, asks only to be allowed to enter the League of Nations as an equal, and through industry and ability to earn a respected position. (General applause). Germany can still aid the world in many ways. It was a German who presented to the workmen of all nations a scientific socialism. We are again on the way to outstrip the world in socialism for we serve socialism which alone can endure, which extols the welfare and culture of the people, and the socialism we serve is becoming a reality. We turn to all the nations of the world with our urgent appeal to proceed with justice towards the German people, and not to destroy our people and our economy by oppression. The German people have gained by fighting the right of self-government within their land, and cannot prostitute themselves to the outside world.

Nor can we refuse to unite the whole German people in a single state. Our German-Austrian brothers have already declared themselves a part of the greater German republic at their National Assembly on November 12th of last year. The German-Austrian Assembly has reiterated its greetings with the great enthusiasm and expressed the hope that our respective National Assemblies will be able to renew the union severed in 1866. German-Austria must be united with the mother country for all time. (Applause). I am sure that I express the opinion of the whole Assembly in greeting this historic announcement [Page 11] directly and full of pleasure and reply to it in hearty brotherhood. Our comrades by race and fate may be assured that we bid them welcome into the new empire of the German Nation with open arms and hearts. (Applause). They belong to us, and we to them. (Applause). I dare also express the expectation that the National Assembly of our future government will very shortly give the authority to treat with the government of the German-Austrian free state in regard to the final coalition. (Applause). Then there will no longer be a boundary fence between us, then we shall really be a single nation of brothers. (Lively applause). Germany must not again fall into a land of disintegration and narrow limits. History and the past prevent the formation of a rigorously centralized state, but the different stocks and dialects must cling together in one nation with one tongue. (Applause). The future of our people can be assured only by the possibility of a large, unified development of our economic life and by a Germany united in policy and capable of action. (Applause). The provisional government has stepped into a very bad inheritance. We were the liquidators of the old regime. (“Very true”, from the left; remonstrance on the right; increased applause on the left.) With the help and support of the Central Council of of the Workmen’s and Soldiers’ Councils (Remonstrance and laughing on the right; Ebert repeated and emphasized the last words; lively applause from the left.) we have used all our strength to overcome the danger and misery of the period of transition. We have done everything to start our economic system functioning again. (Contradiction from right). These continued interruptions (turning to the right) make it clearly apparent that in the grave period of these last weeks and months you have learned exceedingly little. (Stormy applause from the left). If the success of our work did not attain to our wishes, just consideration must be given to the reasons. Many large producers, led astray by the large and sure profits which war industries gave them in the old monarchical, protectionist state have withheld the necessary initiative. We therefore address to these large manufacturers the urgent appeal to further the reawakening of production with all their powers. (Applause).

On the other hand, we call upon the working class to strain every effort in work, which alone can save us. (Applause). We understand the mental mood of those who are now seeking a rest from the strain of overwork during the war, we realize how difficult it must be for those who have been in the field for years to find their way back to peaceful pursuits. But it must be,—we must work and produce goods or we shall go to ruin. (Applause.)

According to our conception, socialism is possible only when the production contains a sufficiently high stage of work done. For us [Page 12] socialism is organization, order and solidarity, not arbitrariness, stubbornness and destruction. (“Quite right”, from the Socialists). The old state could not avoid further extending the state economy to cover the enormous war debts. In the time of universal need, there can be no place for private monopoly and capitalistic profit without work. On that account we want to cut out profit systematically where economic development has made an industry ripe for forming combines. (“Bravo”, from the left).

The future looks at us full of cares, but in spite of all we trust in the inexhaustible power of production of the German Nation. (Applause). The old German principles of might are broken forever. Prussian hegemony, the Hohenzollern army, and the policy of gleaming weapon have been made impossible for us. As November 9, 1918, is bound to March 18, 1848, we must complete here in Weimar the transformation from imperialism to idealism, from world power to spiritual greatness. (Applause).

Even as La Salle’s [Lassalle’s?] influence was but slight on the thinkers and poets of the classic age, so has the age of William with its emphasis on outward splendor passed over us. Now the spirit of Weimar, the spirit of great philosophers and poets, must again fill our lives, fill them with the spirit shown in the second part of “Faust” and in “Wilhelm Meister’s Wanderjahre”; we must not get lost in theory, must not hesitate or vacillate, but take a firm grip on practical life with clear glance and a firm hand, for a man who hesitates at a doubtful moment increases the evil and leads it further and further. But he who clings to reason himself, fashions the world.

So we shall go to work, our great goal clear before our eyes: to guard the rights of the German people, to anchor in Germany a strong democracy and fill it with true social spirit and socialistic ways. (Applause). Thus we will make true that which Fichte gave the German Nation as its task. We will erect an empire of justice and of truth founded on the equality of every human being. (Lively applause from the majority).

  1. Ebert’s speech is printed infra; the accompanying press comments are not printed.
  2. Statement not printed.