Mr. Wilson to Mr. Seward

No. 37.]

Sir: On the 11th instant the Venezuelan congress of 1867 finally assembled, and organized by the election of General Guzman Blanco as president of the [Page 809] senate and José Dolores Landaeta president of the house of deputies. On the succeeding day, the 12th instant, the ministry in a body presented the message of the executive to congress, signed by General Leon Colina, in his capacity of primer designado. That document (a copy of which, and translation of the same is enclosed herewith, marked enclosure No. 1) recommends the following reforms:

1st. Protection of the arts and industrial enterprises, and particularly of agriculture, on account of its social, political, and economical importance.

2d. Reform of the constitution, reducing the number of states, and granting to the government general power sufficient to secure their obedience, and the reform of the judicial power.

3d. Laws explaining the true meaning of the fundamental basis of the union, and establishing their sanction, and determining the power which shall take cognizance of their infraction.

4th. Reduction of the imposts and expenditures.

5th. Reorganization of the public credit.

6th. Laws which shall correct the alleged practice of foreigners in prosecuting their affairs through the diplomatic channel.

7th. Substantial reforms in the matter of public order and of the national police.

Many of these suggestions are undoubtedly worthy of the serious consideration of congress, especially the one in regard to the reduction of the number of states. With a population not exceeding 1,500,000, Venezuela has twenty states. These states are, in fact, whatever may be the theory, sovereign and independent, not only of each other, but, almost, also of the general government. Even in cases of insurrections in the states or invasion of one by another, the general government is denied the power to interfere, unless, indeed, its very existence, in consequence of either, is imperilled. The reform of the constitution, in respect to the number of states, and also granting additional powers to the general government, is urgently asked for in the message, and it is understood that these recommendations are particularly approved by President Falcon, and that all of his influence will be brought to bear to effect their accomplishment.

In regard to the alleged practice of foreigners prosecuting their business through the different legations, I would say that in most cases where such course has been adopted, I believe it to have been a necessity on their part, imposed by the fact that the judicial tribunals of this country are not only dilatory to the last degree, but subject to the suspicion of bribery, and often easily controlled in their action by dislike to foreigners.

It is, however, not one or two reforms that are needed. This government requires a thorough reform in almost every department before it can hope to assume any position among or be respected by other governments. Republicanism in Venezuela is but a name, and is neither comprehended by her people nor desired by her leaders.

I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant,

JAMES WILSON.

Hon. William H. Seward, Secretary of State, Washington, D. C.

[Translation.]

Legislators of my Country: I cordially congratulate you on your having been chosen by Providence to organize, upon a solid basis, the federal system, assailed as well by the prostration consequent upon the great efforts necessary to establish it as by sectional passions and interests.

I trust that, being elected to so exalted a mission, there will not be wanting to you the assistance of the light from on high to accomplish it fully.

[Page 810]

The reassembling of the legislative body is an event that, by its influence upon the common weal, necessarily calls the attention of all citizens who expect of it, as the depositary of the supreme power, salutary rules to govern them in their public and private conduct. For this reason, if congress, disregarding the importance of their august functions, do not correspond to the hopes of their constituents, they end in becoming the cause of the greatest evils, because the citizen, not finding in the institutions and laws the protection he wants, looks upon himself as lost; deems his forlorn situation interminable. Victim of despondency, his patriot ism droops, and in his hatred for the institutions looks for the remedy for his sufferings to extreme means, even to the subversion of public order. Although it is impossible to ascertain at once all the measures indispensable to insure happiness to the nation, nevertheless the public powers are bound to show by their acts that they are working to accomplish it; that they watch, in the first place, over the inestimable boon of peace, acting in such a manner that the interests, well understood, of all the members of society should tend to preserve it, and to this end they should be the foremost in giving the example, since they sanctioned the precept, of respecting what is due to the sacred rights of individuals, inculcating, in order to effect this, in all its members, the knowledge of their rights and their duties; stimulating public instruction in all its branches by protecting, with adequate laws, the arts and enterprises of the country, and, above all, agriculture, this nurse of States, eternal reproducer of the fruits and gifts of the earth, which, furnishing the means of subsistence, augments population, and yielding the prime materials affords abundant nourishment to industry and commerce, thus constituting a perennial stream of riches and prosperity for the nation. For this reason, when agriculture has reached a flourishing condition, all citizens are interested in removing all causes of war, both intestine and foreign, its irreconcilable enemies, which succeeds in this way in becoming a sure guarantee of peace. For this reason governments in all ages of the world, in fulfilment of their most unrelinquishable duty, have endeavored to encourage this first art, innate in man, an unequivocal token of the progressive march or countries and of the consequent welfare of their inhabitants. Submitting to opinion, that legislator of nations, that echo of the voice and of the reason of the people, a principle which, as an enemy to despotism, ought to rule in all free countries, our constitutional chart was framed the most liberal one that the history of nations records. Therein was created the sovereignty of the States, so ample that it came near attacking the federative principle itself; that is, the union principle to constitute a common authority. The institution of a general government supposes the relinquishment or abandonment on the part of the States of a portion of the rights that constitute their absolute sovereignty. To deny this portion to the general government, under any pretext whatever, is to oppose the existence of the federative system; breaking the links that constitute the union, without which, instead of confederated states they would be separate and absolutely independent. If the general government is not to have power sufficient to make itself obeyed within the States, it will have no object, or, rather, there will be no government.

If the federal republic has been saved, during the period it counts of existence, from the evils and horrors of anarchy, it is owing to the omnipotent power of public opinion, because the deficiency of the central power has been supplied by the prestige of the great marshal, seconded by his ardent patriotism, thus furnishing the means most adequate for the people to convince themselves of the necessity of investing the central power with the attributes indispensable for the due performance of its high functions; without this the federation would be an anarchy.

The reform of the constitution has been asked for by the majority of the States; it behooves congress, then, to satisfy this desire by sanctioning measures which, at the same time that they strengthen the central power, do not dismember the autonomy of the States, except in the part necessary for that object. In regard to which I proceed to make those suggestions which I think most indispensable—reduction of the number of the States. This is the point to which those who ask for the reform of the constitution principally confine themselves, impelled, no doubt, by the conviction which they have acquired during the period already transpired, that the multiplicity of weak States, incapable, by their own efforts, of coming out of their stationary and sad situation, of causing themselves to be respected by their neighbor, and of supporting suitably a regular administration, exposes them, at every step, to intestine revolts, and to become victims to the evil passions of some of their own sons, who, in despite of the laws and of the constitutive principles of every society, climb to power, employing means which should precisely banish them perpetually from it. This truth is proved by lamentable occurrences that should be remembered only to be endeavored to be avoided, and so I recommend it to you.

The reduction of the States carries along with it the reform of some other articles of the constitution, among which the judicial power particularly calls your attention, the essential and constitutive basis of all societies, since it is that which decides upon the life, the honor, and property, the three objects most dear to man, at once the motive and end which have led him to constitute himself in society, and without the attainment and real enjoyment of which, vain are so many sacrifices which he has imposed upon himself, vain the suppression of his passions, his respect to the law and the authorities, vain his very devotedness to labor. It is necessary, before anything else be done, to free this power from local influences and from political vicissitudes and instability, to insure which, not only should the nature and amount [Page 811] of business serve as a rule, but the security of men fit to administer justice, which, together with the want of resources, is the cause that in some States the judicial power has not as yet been constituted; that in others there is hardly held the first instance; that in many, in order to satisfy the urgent necessity of its existence, an attempt has been made to repair the evil with one still greater, raising to the rank of judges men who are wanting in the knowledge necessary to act as such, and only fit to divest authority of its lustre, the law of all respect.

Although the constitutional compact establishes the basis of the union in facts, as well as laws and local regulations, it is necessary to say it, the greater part of them have been violated; it is proper, then, to frame laws that, embodying the true meaning of the fundamental basis, shall establish their sanction, and designate the public power which is to apply punishment to the infractor. You must remember that it is the central power that represents the interests of the Venezuelan federation in the great society of nations, to which it alone is amenable for all the acts that, violating the principles of international law, are committed by any State whatever, to the end that you grant to the central power the attributes necessary to avoid and correct them.

The report of the interior and justice will inform you of all relative to the revolts which have unfortunately taken place in some of the States. To-day, notwithstanding, I can assure you that the peace of the republic is re-established; but this is owing solely, it can be so expressed, to the beneficent principle of the authority centred in the great marshal President, who, absent temporarily from the executive administration of the nation, has visited all the points where peace has been disturbed, to return to the country a condition so indispensable to its complete welfare. Without this prestige, without this moral power, without this affluence of authority, based upon his high civic and military endowments, the republic would have fallen into anarchy; being such that, in order to quell it, his clemency and respect for the law—qualities which, for the happiness of Venezuela, are combined in an eminent degree in the present chief of the union—have sufficed. These very disturbances furnish reasons justifying the measures, which I trust you will take, in order to prevent their repetition.

The treasury.—The object of this department is to attend to the expenditures of the nation by means of its contributions; but these expenditures ought to be such as are solely indispensable and economically necessary, and the contributions that exceed these limits are unjust, without there being any power whatever authorized to impose them, because to create expenditures, under whatever title, calculating to pay them with the augmentation of the contributions, is a system highly ruinous to the prosperity of the country, and, besides, contrary to the very end itself that it proposes, because, by impoverishing the citizens, it renders them incapable of paying the contributions, and the treasury impotent to pay its expenditures. It is, therefore, necessary to reduce these expenditures until their proportion be equal to the product of just contributions, and to effect it the list should be reduced of the employés in ail the branches of the administration. In this respect no fear can be entertained that the public service will suffer, because a small number of capable employés, punctually paid and therefore devoted to the rigorous performance of their duties, as might be required of them, would give a result more satisfactory than a large number of employés, less capable, badly compensated, disheartened, and under the necessity of devoting a part of their time to procure the means of subsistence.

In the military list, also, great economy can be introduced, as well as in pensions and reward. In regard to these let me be allowed to plead on behalf of those who legitimately are deserving thereof.

Nothing is more just, nothing more humane, than that the whole nation should contribute to succor those who, in defending their country, have remained unable to procure by their work their daily subsistence; but to grant the same favor to many who are not in this case, is to render it impossible for the treasury, by reason of the increased number of the pensioners, to comply with those truly worthy of this succor, who behold themselves defrauded of a right so well acquired.

I must here urge you to turn your attention to the internal and foreign public debt. It is all-necessary that by well-meditated measures, credit should be sustained, and that there be given to both debts a value which, by its circulation, may tend to raise the arts and agriculture from the state of prostration in which they lie; for it is a principle admitted by all enlightened nations, that the circulation of the national debt is equivalent to the creation of coin, which increases with the credit that measures, wisely combined, cause the debt to enjoy. In the report of this branch you will find further detail upon this point.

Our foreign relations have not suffered any alteration; this is one of the ends to which the government has devoted its attention; the respective reports will inform you of the course which they have taken. The meagreness of our revenues on one part, and the extraordinary augmentation of the expenditures caused by intestine revolts on the other, have not allowed us to comply entirely with the obligations imposed by diplomatic conventions; notwithstanding the regard that our situation has elicited is commendable, and this conduct is a further reason why you should provide some secure means to discharge them.

I must also submit here very particularly to your consideration an abusive practice among foreigners, who prosecute their business through diplomatic channels, it being so that the laws of nations have defined clearly the cases and circumstances in which this recourse [Page 812] ought to be availed of I think, therefore, that you ought to pass a law which, restraining this abuse, shall destroy the unjust difference that exists in this respect between foreigners and Venezuelans, and renders the condition of the former better than that of the latter.

War.—I have already made you acquainted with the motives that obliged the great citizen marshal President to declare himself in campaign service, assuming the command in chief of the army, respecting the operations of which the report of the branch presents to you further details, as likewise the measures of organization which have been introduced, and others which are asked for.

The matter of public works or progress of the country embraces all the branches of the public administration; but herein it is only possible to touch upon those points which I deemmost urgent to organize. The civil legislation of Venezuela is a chaos, wherein are to be found discordant and heterogeneous elements. It consists of the Spanish laws existing up to 1808, and whose origin goes back to the thirteenth century; of the laws of the Indies, I enacted for a people conquered and treated as savages; of a few laws of Colombia, and of those passed by our legislative bodies during the 36 years we count of political existence. The progress, then, of the country needs the, creation of national codes, corresponding to the position we have reached in civilization, which should establish the statutes of law and regulate the proceedings in all the branches of civil legislation. This is a work that requires time, study, and an abundance of special knowledge, theoretical as well as practical, and which only a commission of persons of ability can duly perform. Public order and national policy require also substantial reforms to place them in harmony with the federal institutions that govern us to-day. Public instruction, the germ of the future welfare of the country, demands most especially your careful attention; sanctioning for the purpose a plan well combined, which, imparting unity to studies throughout the republic, may raise them to the height that the federal principles demand that we have proclaimed, and that only concede superiority to talent, to moral endowments, and to patriotism.

Another of the branches of public works is the explanation of our rich territory; the expenditures in its realization that may be incurred will be amply recompensed. Infinitely profitable will be to the enterprises of the country the knowledge of all the productive capacities of the land when once discovered by learned investigation into the three kingdoms of nature.

Statistical reports of the republic and private lands that the republic contains, together with a scientific classification of their suitableness for the different branches of production, are an indispensable basis, both to establish the imposts with justice, and to guarantee public and I private credit; to serve as a powerful auxiliary of immigration and colonization, as well as, finally, to facilitate the opening of roads for communication.

I have sketched the outlines of the measures that the nation most urgently demands: it devolves upon you to develop them without forgetting that you are a power independent of any other power; that the public wants and opinion should be your only guide, and that the best laws are those which are best adapted to the character and nature of the people for whom the laws are made.

May God inspire you in your deliberations.


LEON COLINA.

J. R. Pachano, Minister of the Interior and Justice.

Nicolas Silva, Minister of Treasury.

Vicent Cabrales, Minister of Public Credit.

R. Arvelo, Minister of Public Works.

Juan F. Perez. Minister of War and Marine.

Rafael Seijas, Minister of Foreign Relations.