Mr. Hunter to Mr. Adams

No. 1398.]

Sir: Referring to instructions No. 1315, March 21, and 1317, March 22 last, in regard to the proceedings of the steamer City of Richmond in transferring arms and men to the iron-clad Olinde, or Stonewall, I beg your attention to the enclosed copy of a letter of the 1st instant from the War Department enclosing a copy of a report from Major Ludlow to General Dix, giving the information de-rived from Ernest W. Pratt, the mate, and Robert Green, the steward of the City of Richmond, in relation to the transaction referred to. You will, perhaps, find this information useful in discussing the matter, though it is regretted that it is not in the form of a deposition of the men.

I am, sir, your obedient servant,

W. HUNTER, Acting Secretary.

Charles Francis Adams, Esq., &c., &c., &c.

Mr. Dana to Mr. Seward

Sir: Referring to your letter of the 6th ultimo, asking that the Department of State be furnished with an authenticated copy of such statements as may be elicited from Ernest W. Pratt and Robert Green, two of the crew of the City of Richmond, regarding the transaction in which the Sea King was engaged, conveying men and munitions to the Olinde, I am instructed to transmit the enclosed report from Major General Dix, which he states furnishes all the information obtainable in the case.

I have the honor to be, sir, your obedient servant

C. A. DANA, Assistant Secretary of War.

Hon. William H. Seward, Secretary of State

[Report.]

General: In compliance with your instructions, I have investigated the cases of Ernest W. Pratt and Robert Green, passengers on the Corsica from Nassau, who arrived last evening at 11 o’clock, and were arrested by officer James S. Chalker, of the revenue service, not having the necessary passports, and were brought to these headquarters this morning for examination.

Pratt was secreted in the captain’s room and Green in the purser’s room during the time all the other passengers were being examined by the officer. Pratt was the mate and Green was the steward of the steamer City of Richmond. This steamer, of 455 tons, was owned by Cranshaw, the rebel agent in London; was fitted out there, loaded with coals and provisions at that port, and cleared, with W. Scott as master, about 3d January last for Bermuda, or any of the West India islands, with the understanding, on the part of Pratt and Green, that she was to run the blockade. After leaving London, she dropped down the Thames river about about eighty miles, to a place called Greenhigh’s, and there took on board some boxes of [Page 347] small-arms, between sixty and seventy officers and men, and about three hundred barrels of gunpowder. The regular crew of the City of Richmond was composed of about forty-five officers and men, taken on at London. After shipping the ammunition and men, she steamed for the coast of France, and in about seven days arrived off Belle Isle, when she met the rebel ram Olinde, and at a distance of about four miles from shore. She transferred to this ram all the officers and men taken on at Greenhigh’s, a large quantity of provisions, and about one hundred and fifty barrels of gunpowder and all the small-arms; she then steamed for Bermuda, anchored in the harbor of St. George, where she landed some of her provisions and balance of gunpowder, took in coal, made some repairs, and remained in port about a week. She then went to Nassau, New Providence, where she arrived about the 4th or 5th March instant. After remaining on board in this port about four days, all the officers and men were ordered on shore by Captain Scott, and some functionary was sent from the town to enforce the order. There had been difficulty between the officers and crew and Captain Scott, growing out of the manner in which Captain Scott had discharged the former from the ship. After they had left the ship, Captain Scott gave her into the hands of one Captain Davidson, not a British subject, who had come out in her from London, and was the agent of the owner, Cranshaw. The City of Richmond was at Nassau when the Corsica left.

The above facts I derived from an examination of Pratt and Green. The former made his statements very unwillingly, and only in reply to pressing and searching questions. He knows much more than he admits, and refused to answer many questions I put to him. I have no doubt whatever that he was fully aware of the whole objects of the fitting out the cargo, the passengers, and the destination of ‘the City of Richmond. I enclose herewith the certificate of discharge of Pratt and Green, and the communications to you of Mr. Thomas Kirkpatrick, United States consul, at Nassau, N. P. The Mr. Howell therein referred to gives upon his examination no additional facts to those above stated.

I am, very respectfully, your obedient servant,

WM. H. LUDLOW, Acting Aide-de-Camp, and Acting Inspector General, Department of the East,

Major General John A. Dix, Commanding Department of the East.

[Untitled]

I certify on honor that the facts stated in the foregoing report were derived from the examination of Pratt and Green, except the fact reported of their concealment on board the Corsica, which was reported to me by revenue officer James S. Chalker.

WM. H. LUDLOW, Acting Aide-de-Camp and Acting Inspector General, Department of the East.