File No. 837.51/284

The Secretary of the Treasury ( McAdoo) to the Secretary of State

Dear Mr. Secretary: Under date of November 7, Assistant Secretary Leffingwell wrote you enclosing copy of a letter, dated October 29, from the Cuban Minister, which for the time being terminated negotiations relative to a loan by this Government to the Cuban Government. Mr. Gonzales, our Minister to Cuba, informs me that the Cuban Government has, at the suggestion of the State Department, made commitments for advances to the Cuba Railroad, in order to insure getting out the next Cuban crop, and that, at the suggestion of the Navy Department, has made contracts for the purchase of submarine chasers. Mr. Gonzales further informs me that the Cuban Government has relied upon receiving a loan of $15,000,000 from this Government with which to meet these commitments. I should like to have from you, therefore, a statement of your views in order to ascertain if there is any moral obligation to give Cuba financial assistance. I was not only willing, but glad to make a loan to Cuba, and I was sorry that the Cuban Government encountered legal obstacles for negotiating a loan on the basis that had been outlined. I desire to have the above information because it may be possible, if found advisable, to work out some plan to give at least temporary assistance to Cuba.

Sincerely yours,

W. G. McAdoo

The Secretary of State to the Secretary of the Treasury ( McAdoo)

Sir: I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your communication of November-20, 1917, requesting an expression of opinion from this Department as to whether any moral obligation rests upon the Government of the United States to give Cuba financial assistance. In reply I desire to inform you that an examination of the correspondence passed between the Department and the Cuban Government would appear to show that a certain moral obligation does exist for the reason that the American Minister to Cuba, under instructions from the Department in preliminary conversations respecting the proposed loan, especially recommended to the Cuban Government that a certain portion of this loan, roughly in the neighborhood of $3,000,000, be set aside for the purpose of establishing a credit in favor of the Cuba Railroad, should this railroad guarantee [Page 315] to expend these moneys in the necessary improvements in roadbed and additions to their rolling stock and in repairing the damages done to the road during the last revolution.

Mr. Whigham, President of the Cuba Railroad, informed the American Minister at Habana, that the Cuban Government has assured him of credits in the neighborhood of $3,000,000, upon the statement of which his railroad had undertaken large improvements.

I have [etc.]

Robert Lansing