No. 129.
Mr. Bancroft to Mr. Fish.

No. 460.]

Sir: I inclose to you, in translation, extracts from an elaborate editorial which appeared in the Spener Gazette of the 7th instant. The editor of that paper is a distinguished member of the Prussian Diet and of the German Parliament. I would by no means attribute too much importance to the article, yet I have judged it worthy of your attention as an indication that the German people, though they may prefer to see the Sandwich Islands remain independent, would wish them to form a part of our republic rather than of the dominions of any European power.

I remain, &c.,

GEO. BANCROFT.
[Extracts from an editorial article in the Spener Gazette of February 7, 1873.]

The immediate future of the Sandwich Islands has already been decided by the election of the Prince Lunalilo, known to be a friend to the United States, as king, by a plebiscite, the confirmation of which is as good as certain. The annexation of the islands will be thus deferred, though not made in the long run impossible, for they lie within the legitimate sphere of the United States, and in the hands of that power would do more for themselves and for the world than under their present rule. If the passion for annexation in the direction south of the present territory of the Union is but a bad inheritance of the slave oligarchy, on the other hand the wish for the possession of the Sandwich Islands has a deeper justification, for it will be for the benefit of all civilized nations.

The American Union was the first to awaken the Eastern Pacific countries out of their slumber, and with its ample resources to rouse them to activity, commerce, and industry, in short to introduce a modern development. California is already in regular steam communication with Japan and China; the inhabitants of the celestial empire have taken up the staff and are helping to people the United States. The Japanese are seeking to establish even closer relations with America and Europe. The Pacific Ocean enters into the history through the Americans; here is the legitimate field of their enterprise and power. Their shipping, which, in consequence of narrow laws and protective tariff measures, has been swept from the Atlantic, seeks now the Pacific, where it has all but exclusive empire. There the American mind works in the [Page 278] spirit of progress and of unshackled freedom. The Sandwich Islands are the “halfway house” between America and Asia. Hitherto this little kingdom of the Kanaks, with its 50,000 inhabitants, its constitutional apparatus of two chambers, its responsible ministry, and it’s supreme court, has been but an involuntary play-ball in the hands of English and American missionaries, planters, and merchants. A play-ball will it remain, though now the Americans have got the upperhand. Thus the inhabitants of the islands offer no impediment; they need not even be as the American journals desire, gently exterminated, since five deaths take place to every three births, so that a hundred years ago, in Cook’s time, the population amounted to 400,000 souls. Moreover, the islands yield excellent cotton and sugar in abundance, and the harbor of Honolulu especially is the natural station for the American whalers, who can there most conveniently pass the summer.

The kingdom now established there is an artificial political creation, which will go to pieces whenever its founders no longer find it to their interest to maintain it. The Americans are now the most powerful of the foreigners in numbers, influence, and property. They acquire, by the election of Lunalilo, a still greater importance, and may quietly await the course of events. But however things may result, however long they may go on as they are, the annexation of the Sandwich Islands is a well-founded political requirement, for it is based upon sound principles and civilizing problems, the furtherance of which is also for the interest of Europe, and the absence of which, in the cases of San Domingo and of Cuba, makes the desire for their annexation nothing less than Quixotic.